Multiple Inner join problem

Givens:

Table COMPAREARCH has 1 record,
FID=9056, SUSPECT=9085

Table OWNR has 2 records,
ASERIAL=9056, FULLNAME=JOHNNY
9085 RON

SELECT
COMPAREARCH.FID,
OWNER.FULLNAME,
COMPAREARCH.SUSPECT,
OWNER1.FULLNAME AS FULLNAME1
FROM
COMPAREARCH
INNER JOIN OWNER ON (COMPAREARCH.FID = OWNER.ASERIAL)
INNER JOIN OWNER OWNER1 ON (COMPAREARCH.SUSPECT = OWNER1.ASERIAL)
WHERE
(FINGERID <> SUSPECT)

Given the above query:
The results are 9056 RON 9085 RON

Where the results should have been
9056 JOHNNY 9085 RON